Could the Sycamore Gap Tree come back to life? Experts say Britain's most famous tree could be saved but warn it will take decades to regrow - as police quiz boy, 16, arrested over felling

The felled Sycamore Gap tree could be saved but would take decades to regrow, arboriculturists said as police quizzed a 16-year-old boy arrested over the incident.

Britain's most famous tree had stood in a dip along Hadrian's Wall in Northumberland for around 300 years before it was felled on Wednesday night with a chainsaw.

Northumbria Police then arrested the teenager yesterday on suspicion of causing criminal damage after what the force described as a 'deliberate act of vandalism'. The force said the boy was in police custody and assisting officers with inquiries.

Nature experts claim that the Sycamore Gap stump could grow some new shoots next spring, although it would then take many decades to became a new tree.

The National Trust also said it might be possible to protect the stump so that the tree could regrow, with the organisation now looking into gathering the seeds.

The felling has provoked a furious reaction from environmentalists and MPs, with many feeling 'appalled' and 'saddened' at the loss of such a feature of the landscape.

Jon Stokes, from The Tree Council, told Sky News: 'It is very difficult to know if it will survive for sure, as I haven't seen it in person, but it's worth having hope.

'At this time of year, trees begin to store energy in their roots for next year's growing season - and it is possible that the tree may grow some new shoots next spring.

'If they do appear, they will then take many decades to grow into a new tree - but there may be a chance. We won't know for sure until next spring.'

Other environmentalists said the best way to remember the tree would be with the 'gain of a forest', given that the UK has Europe's second lowest forest cover at about 13 per cent, compared to a 35 per cent average for the continent.

Robert Macfarlane, an environmental humanities professor at Cambridge University, told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: 'I think our focus really shouldn't be on the offender here. It's on culture, it's on us as it were. I would like to see relational thinking arise from this. This is one tree.

'We have a tendency as a nation to be profoundly sentimental about our wildlife and our nature and much less good about affording it the protections that it needs.

'So a couple of ideas - one is that we need greater protection for big, old, venerable standard trees.'

He said the Woodland Trust has been running a campaign called Living Legends asking the Government to give more protection to ancient trees located outside sites that are already legally protected.

Mr Macfarlane added: 'The other thing is the best way to remember the loss of a tree, I would say, is with the gain of a forest. We are drastically deforested.

'So let us reforest the uplands. Let us see natural afforestation take place in the region, in the North, let us see a Sycamore Gap forest rise from the loss of the tree.'

Speaking about the loss of the tree, he also said: 'It's so grim. I felt sick - so many people did when they saw it, that clean wood. And we could see it was such a healthy tree when we could see all of it.

'It was a film star - it starred in Robin Hood Prince of Thieves. It was a tree that ashes were scattered under, marriages were made under, it was a shelter for tired walkers.'

Mr Macfarlane told how the tree had 'survived the winds that howl through that notch' and stood in a wall that was a 'symbol of repression'. 

He added: 'It flourished there. It was a landmark in the region, it was a landmark in the world - it was known worldwide. It was a friend to many.' 

National Trust general manager Andrew Poad told BBC Breakfast today: 'Very healthy tree, we can see that now because of the condition of the stump. It may well regrow a coppice from the stump and if we could nurture that, then that might be one of the best outcomes and then we keep the tree.' 

The National Trust jointly looks after the site with Northumberland National Park, and Mr Poad also expressed 'deep shock' at the incident. 

Tristan Gooley, author of How To Read A Tree, said that the tree should continue to grow unless it was dying.

He told the Daily Telegraph: 'Unless poisoned or on its last legs anyway, most broadleaf trees that are cut down will sprout back up into multi-stemmed trees.'

John Parker, chief executive at the Arboricultural Association, was less positive. He told Sky News that the traditional method of coppicing - where a tree is deliberately cut near to its base – is often used to manage trees.

But he added: 'With a tree that old and a cut that big, the shock will probably kill what is left of the tree.

'There is a chance you might get shoots at the bottom - but the tree will never be able to re-establish itself to the way it was before.'

Gardener and broadcaster Alan Titchmarsh added: 'It may well re-grow but it will most likely become multi-stemmed and not nearly so statuesque. It would really be better if a new one was planted, and carefully watched over.'

In 2003, the tree narrowly escaped damage when a helicopter filming a documentary series, presented by Titchmarsh, crash-landed less than 100ft away. The crew were injured but the tree and Titchmarsh, who was on the ground, were unharmed.

The sycamore was nicknamed Robin Hood's Tree after it featured in the 1991 blockbuster film, Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves, starring Kevin Costner and Morgan Freeman.

Part of the Hadrian's Wall Unesco world heritage site, it has drawn walkers and visitors from all over the globe. And in 2016 it was named Tree of the Year by the Woodland Trust.

But yesterday morning, rangers discovered the tree – which is thought to have been planted in the early 1700s - had been felled overnight.

Photographs showed the sycamore, which is in an isolated spot almost a mile from the nearest road, on its side with its trunk resting on the wall and surrounded by blue and white police tape. Spray paint could be seen just below the cut in the trunk. 

News of the felling provoked a furious reaction. Mary Foy, Labour MP for Durham, said: 'This is a heartbreaking act of mindless vandalism of a much loved, famous landmark in the North East.

'A very sad day which will upset so many people around the country – and across the world.'

Si King, the TV cook and Hairy Biker, posted a video online accusing the 'warped' culprit of 'murdering a sentinel of time and an elemental spirit of Northumberland'.

Jamie Driscoll, North of Tyne mayor, said the perpetrator must be brought to justice: 'People have had their ashes scattered there.

'People have proposed there. I've picnicked there with my wife and kids. It's part of our collective soul.'

Confirming that the tree had been deliberately felled, a spokesman for Northumberland National Park said: 'Sadly, the famous tree at Sycamore Gap has come down overnight.

'We have reason to believe it has been deliberately felled. We are working with the relevant agencies and partners with an interest in this iconic North East landmark.'

Officials warned against visiting the site, near Crag Lough, but yesterday walkers gathered to see the destruction for themselves. One woman laid a single pink rose close to the stump.

Author Amanda Marks, from Otley, Suffolk, who is staying in the area while researching for a book, said the act 'felt like murder'.

She said: 'There was a chap got there two minutes before we did from Northumberland National Park, and he was the first one to see it. And he was obviously straight on the phone saying no, this is sabotage. So somebody's come up there, with a chainsaw, at night.

'Then people started coming and everybody's aghast. You can't believe it. Everybody sat there open mouthed thinking why, and who would do this?' 

Mr Poad of the National Trust, which jointly looks after the site with the national park, expressed 'deep shock'.

Matt Brown, 37, of the nearby Twice Brewed brewery, said the tree appeared to have been cut down 'in an act of malice' by someone who knew how to handle a large chainsaw.

'It was quite a shock to see it lying there,' he said. 'That tree is a real icon. To those of us born in this area, it really means something.

'It looks as though it has been cut through with one stroke, which means the blade must have been about two metres long.

'It seems to be a thought-out and planned act. The tree can be seen from the old military road but to access it you have to climb over barbed wire and walk through marshy ground for a mile.

'This is someone who knows how to fell trees and made sure it toppled in the right direction.'

Alison Hawkins, who lives in Liverpool, was one of the first people on the scene this morning, posting a picture on Facebook of the felled tree with the caption: 'An awful moment for all walking Hadrians wall the Sycamore Gap tree has gone! Not the storm an absolute ******* felled it!!'

Ms Hawkins, who was on her fourth day of walking Hadrian's Wall, said she was 'tearful' when she discovered the tree had been cut down.

She said: 'At first we thought it was because of the storm but then we saw a national park ranger. He said it had been cut down and there was paint around the cut section, so it was a professional who knew where they were going to cut.'

'It was a proper shock. It's basically the iconic picture that everyone wants to see. You can forgive nature doing it but you can't forgive that. 

'We've carried on the walk but news is spreading so we've passed quite a few people asking us if it's true.'

Landscape and nature author Robert Macfarlane said: 'I just feel sick. I feel desperately sad about what it says about our wider relationship with trees and with nature in this country. And I feel very angry.'

He told BBC Radio 5 Live the tree was probably about 300 years old.

He said: 'Just so many memories were stored in that tree and to see that white wood that a chain saw ripped through at some point last night. I just despair really about the state of nature in this country.'

Jack Taylor, from Woodland Trust, told the programme: 'If it's been deliberately felled, as reports suggest, it's totally unforgiveable.'

'And, I'm really struggling to think of a reason why anybody would do that. Honestly, it would have to be a disturbed individual to do something that sort-of deliberate and heinous.'

Mr Taylor said: 'We're completely devastated that this has happened.'

Photographer Ian Sproat, 42, said he felt his 'heart was ripped out', adding: 'They have destroyed a part of the North East. It's like cutting down the Tyne Bridge.'

Since January the illegal felling of trees has been punishable with unlimited fines and prison terms.

Asked about the felling, Rishi Sunak told ITV Tyne Tees and Border: 'The police are currently investigating the incident, so it wouldn't be right for me to comment on that one in particular.'

The Prime Minister added the Government is 'absolutely committed' to protecting the UK's natural landscape.

Heritage minister Lord Parkinson of Whitley Bay said: 'Like everyone across the North East, and far beyond, I am heartbroken at the loss of this iconic part of our nation's heritage.

'It is unfathomable that anyone would want to deny future generations the opportunity to have their lives enriched, as those of so many people from all over the world have been, by this breathtaking site.'

The news was also met with dismay and outrage by walkers' groups on social media.

One Facebook user said: 'I was sat crocheting at the top of the hill earlier this year while my husband and son were climbing up the rock face next to the tree. This is absolutely devastating news. It's such a magical and magnificent place and tree. I can't believe someone would deliberately chop this tree down.'

Another wrote on the national park authority's Facebook page: 'This is terrible news. I visit the tree regularly with my son.

'I wonder if a tree sculptor could turn the felled tree into something to remember it in its place.'

Tim Wickens, trustee of the Northumberland and Newcastle Society, said: 'I'm truly tearful having just seen the images and reporting on the world famous tree at Sycamore gap on Hadrian's wall apparently being deliberately felled last night.

'If it transpires this was a deliberate, it really is an outrageous and despicable act of vandalism that will shock people everywhere.

'It is beyond belief that anyone would consciously seek to destroy such a timeless symbol of the North East's natural beauty and an icon of the Hadrian's Wall World Heritage Site.

'I would urge anyone with useful information to contact the police immediately to help them find those responsible for this awful crime.'

Superintendent Kevin Waring, of Northumbria Police, said: 'This is a world-renowned landmark and the events of today have caused significant shock, sadness and anger throughout the local community and beyond.

'An investigation was immediately launched following this vandalism, and this afternoon we have arrested one suspect in connection with our enquiries.

'Given our investigation remains at a very early stage, we are keeping an open mind.

'I am appealing to the public for information to assist us - if you have seen or heard anything suspicious that may be of interest to us, please let us know.

'Any information - no matter how small or insignificant you think it may be - could prove absolutely crucial to our enquiries.'

Northumbria Police and Crime Commissioner Kim McGuinness said: 'Northumbria Police have acted fast, showing their dedication to the region and now a 16-year-old male is in custody. This senseless crime has forever damaged an icon in the North East.

'I think we all as a region feel shocked at what has happened. Sycamore Gap was a place of happy and moving memories for millions of people, and a symbol of home for people around the world.

'It's important now that we let justice that its course, and my thanks are with our hardworking police officers for their actions today.'

Last week four large sycamores were found to have been deliberately poisoned in protected woodland in Scotland, 125 miles from the Sycamore Gap.

The attack, in Teucheen Wood, in Inchinnan, north-west of Glasgow, came after a mysterious attacker also hacked at branches of other mature trees with a chainsaw in the same area a few months earlier. Both incidents were reported to Police Scotland.

Anyone with information on what happened to the Sycamore Gap is asked to contact police via the Tell Us Something page on the Northumbria Police website or by calling 101 quoting log NP-20230928-0295.